|Year : 2020 | Volume
| Issue : 5 | Page : 27-36
Regenerative capacity of dental pulp stem cells: A systematic review
Adlin S Rosaian1, Gururaj Narayana Rao1, Sunil P Mohan2, Mahalakshmi Vijayarajan1, Rebekkah C Prabhakaran1, Anand Sherwood3
1 Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Pathology and Oral Microbiology, CSI College of Dental Sciences and Research, Madurai, Tamil Nadu, India
2 Department of Oral Pathology, Sree Anjaneya Institute of Dental Sciences, Kozhikode, Kerala, India; Department of Stem Cells and Regenerative Medicine, Sree Anjaneya Institute of Dental Sciences, Kozhikode, Kerala, India
3 Department of Operative Dentistry and Endodontics, CSI College of Dental Sciences and Research, Madurai, Tamil Nadu, India
|Date of Submission||04-Feb-2020|
|Date of Decision||06-Mar-2020|
|Date of Acceptance||13-Mar-2020|
|Date of Web Publication||28-Aug-2020|
Gururaj Narayana Rao
90/57 Gopala Kothan Street, Madurai, Tamil Nadu.
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Objectives: The dental pulp contains undifferentiated mesenchymal cells, blood vessels and so on, which are responsible for routine functions of a tooth. The determination of stemness and regenerative properties using biomarkers and further application in routine practice may unravel its potential. Materials and Methods: Inclusion criteria—original research articles published in English, from 2000 to 2019, were collected both manually and by electronic search from databases of Cochrane, Medline, Embase, and PubMed. Exclusion criteria—articles other than English and review manuscripts were omitted. The shortlisted articles were reviewed for specific biomarkers, to assess the regenerative potential, stemness, and lineage of dental pulp stem cells. Results: Of 512 articles, 64 were selected and reviewed to determine the mesenchymal, neurogenic, vasculogenic, hematopoietic, and stem cell potential. On the basis of the search analysis, a panel of markers was proposed. Conclusion: The application of proposed markers, on a pulpectomized tissue derived from human teeth, may be helpful to determine the regenerative potential and the usefulness in regenerative medicine and tissue engineering.
Keywords: Biomarkers, dental pulp stem cells, regenerative medicine, stem cells, tissue engineering
|How to cite this article:|
Rosaian AS, Rao GN, Mohan SP, Vijayarajan M, Prabhakaran RC, Sherwood A. Regenerative capacity of dental pulp stem cells: A systematic review. J Pharm Bioall Sci 2020;12, Suppl S1:27-36
|How to cite this URL:|
Rosaian AS, Rao GN, Mohan SP, Vijayarajan M, Prabhakaran RC, Sherwood A. Regenerative capacity of dental pulp stem cells: A systematic review. J Pharm Bioall Sci [serial online] 2020 [cited 2020 Sep 20];12, Suppl S1:27-36. Available from: http://www.jpbsonline.org/text.asp?2020/12/5/27/292812
| Introduction|| |
Dental pulp is a type of unique connective tissue that has an anatomical architecture closely restricted by its location within a rigid chamber of tooth. The dental pulp consists of cellular, noncellular components, collagen, and fibrillin fibers. The nonfibrous components include substances that are derived from the extracellular matrix, mainly glycosaminoglycan, proteoglycans, and other adhesion molecules. This matrix plays a pivotal role in the development, migration, division, shape, and function of the tissue. The presence of blood vessels and nerves plays an important role in the physiological functions of the tooth. It has varied functions ranging from detecting stimuli and also initiating and participating in response against insult. Their regenerative capacity is explained on the basis of presence of various cellular constituents of the dental pulp, which includes odontoblasts, fibroblasts, defense, and undifferentiated cells. The undifferentiated group of cells present in pulp tissue comes under the category of postnatal stem cells. Stem cells are seen in the pulp tissue of both adults and children, within the superficial cell-rich zone, underneath the Hoehl’s cell layer. They are believed to originate from the neural crest cells and segregate into different cell types.,
Dental pulp stem cells (DPSCs) are desirable for their unique properties to differentiate into various cell types, which include dentin-producing odontoblasts, neural predecessor cells, chondroblasts, endothelium formative cells, lipocytes, myoblasts, and osteoblasts. DPSCs are mesenchymal cells that constitute one of the most broadly researched cells. Earlier studies have proved that DPSCs can form tissues such as dentin, pulp, and periodontal ligament fibers. These are proved to be a potential stem cell source for orthopedic and orofacial restoration, and it is postulated that these cells may contribute beyond the stomatognathic system.
Regenerative potentials of the dental pulp tissue have been established in various fields such as, cure of neuro-deficit disorders, cardiac-related disorders, muscular disorders (muscular dystrophy), genetic and lifestyle disorders, liver diseases, ophthalmic-related defects, immune diseases, diseases related to the orofacial, bone defects, and infertility treatments. Hence based on the aforementioned facts, systematic review in DPSC was undertaken, which includes various biomarkers having regenerative potential and lineage, and with probable clinical applications were identified.
| Materials and Methods|| |
This review was carried out based on the standard guidelines for making of a systematic review (Prisma Guidelines 2015) [Figure 1].
Inclusion criteria: Original research articles published in English in the year from 2000 to 2019 and related to the title were selected for the review.
Exclusion criteria: Articles other than English language and review manuscripts were excluded. The stem cell markers and regenerative markers were the main method of determination of the potentiality of the dental pulp tissue.
Sources, search strategy, and study selection
Various standardized search engines were used, such as PubMed, Cochrane Library, Embase, and Medline. In addition, a manual search was performed on the personalized collection of journals.
Two oral pathologists reviewed the articles and an experienced reviewer specialized in stem cell gave final decision.
| Discussion|| |
The dental pulp is an intricate tissue that has got multiple potentials and functions to protect the pulp against challenges such as caries or dental trauma. Michael Goldberg had earlier proposed that the knowledge of the inbuilt defense mechanisms employed by the dental pulp has given similar ideas to induce pulp regeneration therapeutically. Ingle’s has observed that multiple growth factors act as important controllers in the instigation of each of the phases of tooth development. This supports the idea of regenerating an entire dentine–pulp complex from the dental pulp tissue itself.
Though earlier studies have been conducted regarding its regenerative potential, a proper categorization of the stem cells derived has not been made. Hence review has been formulated on the following three criteria:
- (1) To determine the maximum number of immunohistochemical markers that were used in determining the potency of the pulpal tissue
- (2) To categorize the markers based on the respective properties such as mesenchymal, multi-lineage potency, vasculogenic, neurogenic, osteogenic, musculogenic, dentinogenic, and hematopoietic, thereby confirming the pluripotent nature of the pulpal tissue
- (3) To derive a standardized protocol of panel of markers.
Markers used by various authors and its application in the pulp are systematically analyzed in this review [Table 1]. On the basis of the results, the multi-lineage potency of the dental pulp tissue predicted by various markers has been tabulated [Table 2].
|Table 1: The type of markers used by various authors and the interpretations derived,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,|
Click here to view
A panel of markers is proposed based on the markers used frequently by different authors, which shows the multi-lineage capacity and to support our aim of this review [Table 3].
|Table 3: Proposed markers as investigation protocol for stemness and regeneration|
Click here to view
| Conclusion|| |
DPSC has a multi-lineage capacity, proved by various studies. The pulp tissue, which is considered as biological waste following extraction and endodontic treatment, can be harvested for the study. DPSC being mesenchymal and neuroectodermal origin has great potency for various therapeutic and regenerative purposes. It is imperative to study about this tiny tissue and its potential. On the basis of our review, we suggest that preservation of dental pulp tissue and subjecting them to the panel of biomarkers such as CD146, CD 73, CD 105, STRO-1, and SOX-2 will unravel its regenerative potential and lineage. The limitation of this analysis is that the panel of markers proposed is yet to apply practically in a pulp tissue to confirm its viability.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Bakhtiar H, Mazidi SA, Mohammadi Asl S, Ellini MR, Moshiri A, Nekoofar MH, et al
. The role of stem cell therapy in regeneration of dentine-pulp complex: a systematic review. Prog Biomater 2018;7:249-68.
Yang X, Li L, Xiao L, Zhang D Recycle the dental fairy’s package: overview of dental pulp stem cells. Stem Cell Res Ther 2018;9:1-8.
Sloan AJ, Waddington RJ Dental pulp stem cells: what, where, how? Int J Paediatr Dent 2009;19:61-70.
Ledesma-Martínez E, Mendoza-Núñez VM, Santiago-Osorio E Mesenchymal stem cells derived from dental pulp: A review. Stem Cells Int 2016;2016:12.
Apel C, Forlenza OV, de Paula VJ, Talib LL, Denecke B, Eduardo CP, et al
. The neuroprotective effect of dental pulp cells in models of Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s disease. J Neural Transm 2009;116:71-8.
Gandia C, Armiñan A, García‐Verdugo JM, Lledó E, Ruiz A, Miñana MD, et al
. Human dental pulp stem cells improve left ventricular function, induce angiogenesis, and reduce infarct size in rats with acute myocardial infarction. Stem Cells 2008;26:638-45.
Yang G, Zhou J, Teng Y, Xie J, Lin J, Guo X, et al
. Mesenchymal TGF‐β signaling orchestrates dental epithelial stem cell homeostasis through Wnt signaling. Stem Cells 2014;32:2939-48.
Carnevale G, Pisciotta A, Riccio M, Bertoni L, De Biasi S, Gibellini L, et al
. Human dental pulp stem cells expressing STRO‐1, c‐kit and CD34 markers in peripheral nerve regeneration. J Tissue Eng Regen Med 2018;12: e774-85.
Gomes JA, Monteiro G, Melo GB, Smith RL, Cavenaghi M, Lizier NF, et al
. Corneal reconstruction with tissue-engineered cell sheets composed of human immature dental pulp stem cells. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2010;51:1408-14.
Hattori Y, Kim H, Tsuboi N, Yamamoto A, Akiyama S Therapeutic potential of stem cells from human exfoliated deciduous teeth in models of acute kidney injury. 2015;1-18.
Kamioka H Preferred reporting items for systematic review and metaanalysis protocols (prisma-p) 2015 statement. Japanese Pharmacol Ther 2019;47:1177-85.
Goldberg M The dental pulp. Berlin Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag; 2014.
Ingle JI, Bakland LK, Baumgartner JC Ingle’s endodontics 6. Hamilton, Ontario: BC Decker; 2008.
Pushpalatha C, Nimbal A, Jain S, Tammannavar P Dental pulp stem cells scope in dentistry; a review. IOSR-JDMS 2013;8:38-41.
Cordeiro MM, Dong Z Dental pulp tissue engineering with stem cells from exfoliated deciduous teeth. JOEN 2008;34:962-9. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2008.04.009.
Shetty H, Kakade A, Shetty S, Neelakantan P, Nagar S, Desai RS, et al
. Immunohistochemical characterization of stem cell and differentiation markers of the dental pulp of human natal teeth. Futur Sci OA 2018;4:FSO342.
Huang GT, Yamaza T, Shea LD, Djouad F, Kuhn NZ, Tuan RS, et al
. Stem/progenitor cell-mediated de novo regeneration of dental pulp with newly deposited continuous layer of dentin in an in vivo model. Tissue Eng Part A 2010;16:605-15.
Gronthos S, Brahim J, Li W, Fisher LW, Cherman N, Boyde A, et al
. Stem cell properties of human dental pulp stem cells. Journal of Dental Research 2002;81:531–5.
Teti G, Salvatore V, Focaroli S, Durante S, Mazzotti A, Dicarlo M, et al
. In vitro osteogenic and odontogenic differentiation of human dental pulpstem cells seeded on carboxymethyl cellulosehydroxyapatite hybrid hydrogel. Frontiers in physiology2015;6:1-10.
Chaubron F, De Vos J, Cuisinier FJ, Cuisinier FJ Allogenic banking of dental pulp stem cells for innovative therapeutics. World journal of stem cells2015;7:1010-21.
Yasui T, Mabuchi Y, Morikawa S, Onizawa K, Akazawa C, Nakagawa T, et al
. Isolation of dental pulp stem cells with high osteogenic potential. Inflamm Regen 2017;37:8.
Chen YY, He ST, Yan FH, Zhou PF, Luo K, Zhang YD, et al
. Dental pulp stem cells express tendon markers under mechanical loading and are a potential cell source for tissue engineering of tendon-like tissue. Int J Oral Sci 2016;8:213-22.
Ferro F, Spelat R, Beltrami AP, Cesselli D, Curcio F Isolation and characterization of human dental pulp derived stem cells by using media containing low human serum percentage as clinical grade substitutes for bovine serum. 2012;7:1-9.
Eleuterio E, Trubiani O, Sulpizio M, Di Giuseppe F, Pierdomenico L, Marchisio M, et al
. Proteome of human stem cells from periodontal ligament and dental pulp. PLoS One 2013;8:e71101.
Urraca N, Memon R, El-Iyachi I, Goorha S, Valdez C, Tran QT, et al
. Characterization of neurons from immortalized dental pulp stem cells for the study of neurogenetic disorders. Stem Cell Res 2015;15:722-30.
Tatullo M, Marrelli M, Shakesheff KM, White LJ Dental pulp stem cells : function, isolation and applications in regenerative medicine. J Tissue Eng Regen Med 2015;9:1205-16.
Stomatol WJ Contents. World J Stomatol2019;6263:1-19.
La Noce M, Paino F, Spina A, Naddeo P, Montella R, Desiderio V, et al
. Dental pulp stem cells: state of the art and suggestions for a true translation of research into therapy. J Dent 2014;42:761-8.
Tamaoki N, Takahashi K, Tanaka T, Ichisaka T, Aoki H, Takeda-Kawaguchi T, et al
. Dental pulp cells for induced pluripotent stem cell banking. Journal of Dental Research 2010;89:773-8.
Sueyama Y, Kaneko T, Ito T, Okiji T Effect of lipopolysaccharide stimulation on stem. Endodontic Journal2018;51:107-14.
Casagrande L, Cordeiro MM, Nör SA, Nör JE Dental pulp stem cells in regenerative dentistry. Odontology 2011;99:1-7.
Rodas-Junco BA, Canul-Chan M, Rojas-Herrera RA, De-la-peña C, Niccan GI Stem cells from dental pulp: what epigenetics can do with your tooth. Front Physiol 2017;8:999.
Shi S, Gronthos S Perivascular niche of postnatal mesenchymal stem cellsin human bone marrow and dental pulp. J Bone Miner Res 2003;18:696-704.
Karaöz E, Demircan PC, Sağlam Ö, et al
. Human dental pulp stem cells demonstrate better neural and epithelial stem cell properties than bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells. Histochem Cell Biol 2011;136:455-73.
Zhang C, Zhang Y, Feng Z, Zhang F, Liu Z, Sun X, et al
. Therapeutic effect of dental pulp stem cell transplantation on a rat model of radioactivity-induced esophageal injury. Cell Death Dis 2018;9:738. doi:10.1038/s41419-018-0753-0.
Miura M, Gronthos S, Zhao M, Lu B, Fisher LW, Robey PG, et al
. SHED : Stem cells from human exfoliated deciduous teeth. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2003;100:5807-12.
Courtenay JC, Deneke C, Lanzoni EM, Costa CA, Bae Y, Scott JL, et al
. Modulating cell response on cellulose surfaces; tunable attachment and scaffold mechanics. Cellulose (Lond) 2018;25:925-40.
Palucka T Bottom-gate geometry increases materials options in all polymer integrated circuits. MRS Bull 2000;25:7-8.
Atari M, Gil-Recio C, Fabregat M, Garcı D, Casals N, Prosper F, et al
. Dental pulp of the third molar : a new source of pluripotent-like stem cells. 2010;125:3343-56.
Arthur A, Rychkov G, Shi S, Koblar SA, Gronthos S Adult human dental pulp stem cells differentiate toward functionally active neurons under appropriate environmental cues. Stem Cells 2008; 26:1787-95.
Askari N, Yaghoobi MM, Shamsara M Tetracycline regulated expression of OLIG2 gene in human dental pulp stem cells lead to mouse sciatic nerve regeneration upon transplantation. Neuroscience 2015;305:197-208. doi:10.1016/j.neuroscience.2015.07.088.
Park Y, Cha S, Park Y Regenerative applications using tooth derived stem cells in other than tooth regeneration: a literature review. Stem Cells Int 2016;2016:9305986.
Akpinar G, Kasap M, Aksoy A, Duruksu G, Gacar G, Karaoz E Phenotypic and proteomic characteristics of human dental pulp derived mesenchymal stem cells from a natal, an exfoliated deciduous, and an impacted third molar tooth. Stem Cells Int 2014;2014:457059.
Tsai AI, Hong HH, Lin WR, Fu JF, Chang CC, Wang IK, et al
. Isolation of mesenchymal stem cells from human deciduous teeth pulp. Biomed Res Int 2017;2017:2851906.
Gronthos S, Mankani M, Brahim J, Robey PG, Shi S Postnatal human dental pulp stem cells (DPSCs) in vitro and in vivo. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2000;97:13625-30.
Huang GT, Gronthos S, Shi S Mesenchymal stem cells derived from dental tissues vs. those from other sources: their biology and role in regenerative medicine. Journal of Dental Research 2009;88:792-806.
Kiraly M, Porcsalmy B, Pataki A, Kádár K, Jelitai M, Molnár B, et al
. Simultaneous PKC and cAMP activation induces differentiation of human dental pulp stem cells into functionally active neurons. Neurochem Int 2009;55:323-32.
Téclès O, Laurent P, Zygouritsas S, Burger AS, Camps J, Dejou J, et al
. Activation of human dental pulp progenitor/stem cells in response to odontoblast injury. Arch Oral Biol 2005;50:103-8.
Kang KJ, Ryu CJ, Jang YJ Identification of dentinogenic cell-specific surface antigens in odontoblast-like cells derived from adult dental pulp. Stem Cell Res Ther 2019;10:128.
Bressan E, Ferroni L, Gardin C, Pinton P, Stellini E, Botticelli D, et al
. Donor age-related biological properties of human dental pulp stem cells change in nanostructured scaffolds. PLoS One 2012;7:e49146.
Fistonich C, Zehentmeier S, Bednarski JJ, Miao R, Schjerven H, Sleckman BP, et al
. Cell circuits between B cell progenitors and IL-7+ mesenchymal progenitor cells control B cell development. The Journal of Experimental Medicine 2018;215:2586-99.
Wang Z, Pan J, Wright JT, Bencharit S, Zhang S, Everett ET, et al
. Putative stem cells in human dental pulp with irreversible pulpitis: an exploratory study. Journal of Endodontics 2010;36:820-5.
Marion NW, Mao JJ Mesenchymal stem cells and tissue engineering. Methods in Enzymology 2006;420:339-61.
Nosrat IV, Smith ÃCA, Mullally ÃP, Olson L, Nosrat CA Dental pulp cells provide neurotrophic support for dopaminergic neurons and differentiate into neurons in vitro ; implications for tissue engineering and repair in the nervous system. 2004;19:2388-98.
Moslemi N, Nazarian H Autologous dental pulp stem cells in regeneration of defect created in canine periodontal tissue. J Oral Implantol 2013;39:433-43. doi:10.1563/AAID-JOI-D-12-00027.
Martens W, Martens W, Wolfs E, Struys T, Politis C, Bronckaers A Lambrichts I: expression pattern of basal markers in human dental pulp stem cells and tissue. Cells Tissues Organs 2012;196:490-500.
Kerkis I, Kerkis A, Dozortsev D, Stukart-Parsons GC, Gomes Massironi SM, Pereira LV, et al
. Isolation and characterization of a population of immature dental pulp stem cells expressing OCT-4 and other embryonic stem cell markers. Cells Tissues Organs 2006;184:105-16.
Liu H, Gronthos S, Shi S Dental pulp stem cells. Methods Enzymol 2006;419:99-113.
Al-Zer H, Kalbouneh H Dental pulp stem cells-derived schwann cells for peripheral nerve injury regeneration. Neural Regeneration Research 2015;10:1945-6.
Li Y, He L, Pan S, Zhang L, Zhang W, Yi H, et al
. Three-dimensional simulated microgravity culture improves the proliferation and odontogenic differentiation of dental pulp stem cell in PLGA scaffolds implanted in mice. Mol Med Rep 2017;15:873-8.
Mead B, Logan A, Berry M, Leadbeater W, Scheven BA Dental pulp stem cells, a paracrine-mediated therapy for the retina. Neural Regeneration Research 2014;9:577-8.
Ishkitiev N, Yaegaki K, Imai T, Tanaka T, Nakahara T, Ishikawa H, et al
. High-purity hepatic lineage differentiated from dental pulp stem cells in serum-free medium. J Endod 2012;38:475-80.
Hatab T, Kochaji N, Issa N, Nadra R, Saleh M, Rahmo A, Rekab M In vivo and immunohistochemical study of dentin and pulp tissue regeneration in the root canal. Journal of Chemical and Pharmaceutical Research 2015;7:302-10.
Karaöz E, Nur B, Gulçin A, Serap G, Ayhan S, Seda Z, et al
. Isolation and in vitro
characterisation of dental pulp stem cells from natal teeth. Histochem Cell Biol 2010;133:95-112.
Aurrekoetxea M, Garcia-Gallastegui P, Irastorza I, Luzuriaga J, Uribe-Etxebarria V, Unda F, et al
. Dental pulp stem cells as a multifaceted tool for bioengineering and the regeneration of craniomaxillofacial tissues. Frontiers in Physiology 2015;289:1-10.
Ebrahimi Dastgurdi M, Ejeian F, Nematollahi M, Motaghi A, Nasr-Esfahani MH Comparison of two digestion strategies on characteristics and differentiation potential of human dental pulp stem cells. Arch Oral Biol 2018;93:74-9.
Ferro F, Spelat R, D’Aurizio F, Puppato E, Pandolfi M, Beltrami AP, et al
. Dental pulp stem cells differentiation reveals new insights in oct4a dynamics. PLoS One 2012;7: e41774.
Demarco FF, Conde MC, Cavalcanti BN, Casagrande L, Sakai VT, Nör JE, et al
. Dental pulp tissue engineering. Brazilian Dental Journal 2011;22:3-13.
Luzuriaga J, Pastor-Alonso O, Encinas JM, Unda F, Ibarretxe G, Pineda JR Human dental pulp stem cells grown in neurogenic media differentiate into endothelial cells and promote neovasculogenesis in the mouse brain. Front Physiol 2019;10:347.
de Cara SPHM, Origassa CST, de Sá Silva F, Moreira MSNA, de Almeida DC, Pedroni ACF, et al
. Angiogenic properties of dental pulp stem cells conditioned medium on endothelial cells in vitro and in rodent orthotopic dental pulp regeneration. Heliyon 2019;5:e01560.
Kushnerev E, Shawcross SG, Sothirachagan S, Carley F, Brahma A, Yates JM, et al
. Regeneration of corneal epithelium with dental pulp stem cells using a contact lens delivery system. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2016;57:5192-9.
Rodas-Junco BA, Villicaña C Dental pulp stem cells: current advances in isolation, expansion and preservation. Tissue Eng Regen Med 2017;14:333-47.
Atari M, Gil-Recio C, Fabregat M, García-Fernández D, Barajas M, Carrasco MA, et al
. Dental pulp of the third molar: a new source of pluripotent-like stem cells. J Cell Sci 2012;125:3343-56.
Abou-Asi MAA, Farré NC, Tarrida LG, Padró EF Pluripotent stem cells obtained from dental pulp. U.S. Patent No. 9,017,663. Washington, DC: U.S. Patent and Trademark Office; 2015.
Ferro F, Spelat R, D’Aurizio F, Puppato E, Pandolfi M, Beltrami AP, et al
. Dental pulp stem cells differentiation reveals new insights in Oct4A dynamics. PLoS One 2012;7:e41774.
Ferro F, Spelat R, Beltrami AP, Cesselli D, Curcio F Isolation and characterization of human dental pulp derived stem cells by using media containing low human serum percentage as clinical grade substitutes for bovine serum. PLoS One 2012;7:e48945.
Hatab T, Kochaji N, Issa N, Nadra R, Saleh M, Rahmo A, et al
. In vivo and immunohistochemical study of dentin and pulp tissue regeneration in the root canal. J Chem Pharm Res 2015;7:302-10.
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4]